The September jobs report shows stronger-than-expected growth, with 254,000 jobs added. However, when combined with data from the new Talent Market Index from Recruitics, it becomes evident that challenges persist, particularly in rising talent attraction costs and mismatches between available skills and job openings.

Total nonfarm employment rose by 254,000, but challenges persist with labor mismatches, increasing costs for talent attraction in key industries, and ongoing shortages in specialized roles. Recruiters are still walking a tightrope, juggling between finding the right candidates and facing new economic headwinds.

254,000 Jobs Added—But Where Are the Candidates?

September saw a notable increase of 254,000 jobs, outpacing the average monthly gain over the past year. Sectors like food services (+69,000) and health care (+45,000) experienced gains, while construction (+25,000) also trended upward. Yet, these numbers don’t tell the full story for recruiters on the ground.

The healthcare sector, for example, saw fewer added jobs compared to its 12-month average—showing the strain of trying to keep pace with ongoing demand and demographic shifts. The September Talent Market Index also reported an 11.88% month-over-month increase in talent attraction prices for health care, driven by intensified competition for a shrinking pool of skilled professionals.

Construction, social assistance, and government roles also experienced steady gains. However, while the job additions are promising, the underlying labor force participation rate held at 62.7% for the third straight month, and the unemployment rate barely budged at 4.1%. The jobs are there, but the talent is either unavailable or insufficient to meet the demand.

Healthcare, Hospitality, and IT: Talent Costs Are Skyrocketing

If your hiring focus is in healthcare, hospitality, or IT, you’re likely feeling the pinch. According to the Talent Market Index, healthcare saw talent attraction costs rise 35.12% year-over-year, and IT prices surged by 112.39% over the same period—thanks to the demand for expertise in AI, cybersecurity, and cloud computing. For hospitality, although hiring costs dipped after the summer peak, they are still up 223.67% year-over-year.

While some sectors, like retail and transportation, are seeing a cooling effect, the divergences make it clear that a one-size-fits-all approach to talent attraction won’t work. Recruitment strategies must evolve with the shifting landscape—requiring adaptable and flexible tactics.

Layoffs in Tech and the Unemployment Rate: More Complexity for Recruiters

Layoffs in tech have surged again—40,000-plus in August—and although this has introduced new skilled candidates to the job market, their expertise may not align with where the demand is growing. Unemployment among IT professionals remains volatile, and while there’s an influx of applicants, the cost to attract top tech talent continues to rise.

The unemployment rate dipped slightly from August’s 4.2% to 4.1%, and the number of people unemployed for less than five weeks decreased significantly. This sounds positive, but the labor force participation rate remained flat, suggesting that talent availability isn’t significantly improving. As recruiters, it’s time to double down on proactive strategies to engage talent.

Key Takeaways for Recruitment

• Industry-Specific Strategies Are Key: With escalating hiring costs in healthcare, IT, and hospitality, focusing on tailored recruitment efforts that prioritize employer branding, flexibility, and career growth is essential. Money may talk, but with budget constraints, companies must get creative in showcasing their value propositions.
• Proactive Recruitment: Expecting to source talent purely through job postings won’t cut it. Passive candidate engagement, direct sourcing, and pipeline development are critical. Consider beefing up internal upskilling programs too—we’re not just recruiting anymore; we’re cultivating.
• Retention Matters More Than Ever: With rising costs of talent attraction, losing your current skilled workers can be a one-two punch that’s hard to recover from. Enhance retention efforts and invest in career growth pathways for existing staff.
• Wage Growth vs. Inflation: Average hourly earnings grew by 4% year-over-year, but many industries are scaling back aggressive wage hikes amid economic pressures. Non-monetary benefits like culture, flexibility, and work-life balance are increasingly critical to attract talent without blowing the budget.

Looking Ahead

The September jobs report and Talent Market Index both indicate that change is constant, and adaptability is essential. Rising hiring costs, sector-specific labor mismatches, and wage pressures are just a few of the hurdles.

The way forward is to embrace a multi-faceted, nuanced approach to talent acquisition.

Focus on building pipelines, make your value proposition as compelling as possible, and remember that in this market, recruiters need to act as both marketers and talent advisors.

Rod Hess

---

Rod Hess is a marketing mad man, but more Doc Brown than Don Draper. Rod is the Content Marketing Director for Talivity (formerly RecruitmentMarketing.com) and has been working in online marketing and advertising for over 15 years. He's been featured in publications like Forbes and Mashable. If you catch him tapping a pencil or bouncing his leg, it's because his brain never turns off. He's just dreaming up his latest AI scheme.